1. The Presentation
The defense begins with the student presenting a comprehensive overview of their dissertation. This typically includes the following key elements:
- Research Question and Objectives: Explaining the central focus of the research and its academic or practical relevance.
- Methodology: Discussing the methods and techniques used to gather and analyze data.
- Findings and Contributions: Presenting the results and how they contribute to the field.
- Implications: Reflecting on how the research might influence future studies, practices, or policies.
In a Berkeley EECS dissertation, the student might use graphs, charts, or diagrams to present complex data analysis results. The presentation should be concise and tailored to the audience's level of expertise.
2. The Question and Answer Session
Following the presentation, the committee will ask the student questions about the research. These questions may focus on areas such as:
- The rationale behind choosing a specific methodology
- The validity and reliability of the research findings
- The potential implications or limitations of the work
The committee may also ask questions related to literature reviews, gaps in the research, or how the work connects to existing studies. For a UC Berkeley EECS dissertation, expect highly technical questions about algorithms, system architectures, or computational models.
3. Feedback and Revisions
After the questioning session, the committee will provide feedback on the dissertation. In most cases, they will suggest revisions to improve clarity, coherence, or to address gaps in the research. This feedback could involve minor edits or more substantial revisions. Students should be prepared to take notes and incorporate this feedback into their final submission.